FREMONT COUNTY, Idaho — Lori Vallow Daybell was issued back-to-back fixed life sentences without the possibility of parole after being convicted in the murders of her children and her husband's previous wife. The sentencing hearing began with relatives' victim impact statements.
RELATED | Lori Vallow Daybell sentencing: Here's what to expect
The court first heard from Samantha Gwilliam, the sister of Tammy Daybell. Gwilliam started by reading the statement prepared by her father, Ronald Douglas on behalf of Tammy's parents. Douglas' statement focused on the lost relationships caused by the actions Lori has been found guilty of, the loss of their daughter, of their now estranged grandchildren, and the acceleration of Leukemia due to the stress of losing a daughter and the trial, leading to the death of Tammy's mother, Phyllis, this past June. The statement concluded with a reminder to Lori that she would answer to the laws of God.
Gwilliam continued with her own victim impact statement, first acknowledging that she had felt something was very wrong when her sister died and continued with the list of lies that Tammy's family had been told by Chad and Lori.
Samantha Gwilliam to Lori Vallow: “you are a liar, an adulteress, and a murderer.”
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
“you are not an exalted human being.. No angels are coming to rescue you…”
The morning continued with Tammy's aunt, Vicki Hogan. Hogan reiterated the loss of the Douglas family due to Tammy's death, and the toll it has taken on them.
Kay Woodcock then took the podium. Kay is the biological grandmother of JJ Vallow, directly addressing Lori, calling her a money-hungry monster.
Kay: “[Lori] is a money hungry power mongering monster.”
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
She emotionally says JJs death has left a gaping hole in their hearts and this world.
Kay first talked about the loss of her brother, Charles Vallow, and the lack of respect shown by Lori to the family. The rest of her statement was focused on the life and light of JJ Vallow, and the love of JJ's big sister Tylee.
Kay finished by saying that Lori Vallow Daybell is a danger to society, driven by greed and her need to be the center of attention, noting that Lori has shown no remorse for the murders of her children.
The State witnesses concluded with the reading of the statement submitted by Colby Ryan, the older sibling to Tylee and JJ. Colby commented on how the children will never have the chance to grow into the people they were intended to be, and how Colby's own children have been robbed of their aunt and uncle. "I've lost my entire family in life, losing the ability to share them in my life. I've lost my sister, brother, father and mother." Colby's statement concludes with prayers for healing for all involved.
Before entering their recommendation for sentencing, the State addressed the court about the lives of the victims, pointing out that within a year of Lori meeting Chad Daybell, Lori's husband, two children, and her boyfriend's wife were all dead. Also expressing that Lori is a threat to society, as she has been found to be responsible for three murders in the span of six weeks.
RELATED | Death penalty no longer an option for Lori Vallow Daybell
The State submitted a sentencing recommendation of life in prison without any chance of release, believing that, due to her actions and lack of remorse for her actions, rehabilitation is not possible. They also requested fines of up to $250,000 be paid as restitution to the next of kin of the victims and the Dept. of Treasury for repayment of funds stolen.
The state asks for a sentence of life without parole. “Lori has proven she’s a danger to society.”
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
Remarks by the defense opened the afternoon session in the sentencing hearing where they stated that hate cannot heal the hurting of the victims and families of the victims, only love and peace can help heal. The defense says Lori's motto is "Love is the Key", and if everyone knew her the way the defense does, they would know she is about love.
Defense: “Lori is a very misunderstood person…. She is about love.”
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
The defense continued with remarks referring to Lori as a good mother, a caring mother, and someone who loved her children, leaning on "hope" for the rehabilitation and consideration for Lori.
The defense stated that Lori's life has already been saved by taking the death penalty off the table, asking for a maximum sentence of 20 years. They argued giving a life sentence provides her no hope and no incentive for rehabilitation. With hope for release, Lori will be incentivized to become a better person according to the defense.
Lori Vallow then addressed the court, speaking from scripture.
Vallow expressed her mourning for JJ and Tylee, and Tammy, and remarked that no one was murdered in this case, saying that accidental deaths happen.
Lori Vallow Daybell speaks at sentencing:
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
She tears up saying she mourns the death of her children and Tammy like everyone else … but “Jesus Christ Christ knows that no one was murdered in this case.”
She recalled an out-of-body experience during the birth of Tylee, and claimed that this has given her access to communicating with people in Heaven. She also stated that she has, additionally, had communication with Jesus Christ.
She continued, explaining that she communicates with her children and with her "friend Tammy Daybell," claiming that she, Lori, does not fear death, but looks forward to it, to get to Heaven.
Lori went on to say that Tylee is now free of the pain of her physical life, and has visited her saying she is fine. She says the same of JJ, that he has visited her saying that he is fine and happy where he is.
Her statement also included multiple references to her friend, Tammy Daybell.
She called Tammy Daybell her “eternal friend” and knows she is so happy and busy in the spirit world. “I have a great love for Tammy.”
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
She says her children and Tammy “rest safely in the arms of Jesus” and she looks forward to the day she too rests in the arms of Jesus.
Upon the conclusion of her statement, Judge Boyce asked if Lori felt she was adequately represented in her defense, to which she agreed.
Then he put forth his sentence.
After all considerations, he felt there are mental health issues present, and found that Lori has been respectful of the court proceedings. He also referenced a doctor's observation that Lori suffers from a delusional disorder, among others, and that a drastic change in her behavior is evident.
However, she is a mother, who has been found guilty of killing her children and the mother of a family of children. He pointed out the other options that Lori had, having other people take guardianship of her children and divorce, but instead chose the most treacherous of outcomes.
He stated that he has not seen any expression of remorse for forever altering the lives of many, many people.
Judge Boyce: “the most shocking thing is a mother killing her children and still you show no remorse.”
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
“You still haven’t said you’re sorry.”
He acknowledged that she may not believe she is guilty of anything, based on her religious beliefs, but the judge explained he is imposing a sentence in the name of justice.
With that, Lori Vallow Daybell has been sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of parole.
Three consecutive life sentences for each deceased victim. Two additional counts for conspiracy in deaths of JJ and tylee will be served concurrently.
— Karen Lehr (@KarenLehr) July 31, 2023
So 3 fixed back to back life sentences with no parole plus 5-10 years for the grand theft charge.
The court also granted the payment of fines as requested by the state with slight modifications.
Lori Vallow will be transported to an Idaho state women's prison, likely the Pocatello facility, though she still has outstanding charges in Arizona for her involvement in the deaths of her fourth husband, Charles Vallow, and her ex-nephew Brandon Boudreaux.
